PALESTINE
The real enemy of the Jews
By Robert
Thompson
AxisofLogic.com
February 5, 2005 -- I
have read with considerable interest the item from Electronic Intifada of
4th February 2005 by Professor Avi Shlaim of Saint Antony's College,
Oxford. His analysis is to my mind a sadly clear example of a serious
misconception common among many excellent persons, as I am sure he is, who
are unwilling to look at reality. He has failed to realise the fact that
for many of us, who have no fear of (or any resultant hatred for) Jews,
the mere idea of a state based on religious affiliation, however important
or unimportant it may be in the lives of the individuals concerned, as the
criterion for being a full citizen.
On the other hand, I
agree with him that Zionism is indeed the real enemy of the Jews, but he
has avoided the basic issue of the invasion of the lands and homes of the
people of Palestine, mainly Muslim or Christian, by the waves of Zionist
immigrants (mainly in the beginning from Europe) whose self-appointed
"leaders" managed to trick the world into believing that one ghastly and
horrific wrong justified another.
We must never forget
the horrors of the Tsarist and Nazi persecutions of those whom they
defined as Jews, and nobody could condemn them more strongly than I do,
but this cannot justify, as it never has, the invasion of the Holy Land.
Professor Shlaim's comments on the behaviour of the most extreme Zionists
do not excuse those who gave or give their support to the seizure (before,
during and after the British Mandate) of lands occupied by indigenous
Palestinians whose families had lived there for centuries.
The history of the
organisation set up to acquire as much Palestinian land as possible, the
KKL (Keren Kayemet l'Israel - Jewish National Fund, thus also known as JNF),
is a lesson of how good intentions can pave the way to hell. This body
started its life by buying up lands (held by absentee landlords) in
Palestine, and then evicting the tenants whose families had lived there
for centuries. The KKL seems to have benefitted from the support of the
Ottoman, and then the British, authorities and was able in this manner to
achieve ethnic cleansing from a time dating back to before the First World
War. This tendency accelerated shortly before, during and after, the
Second World War when Zionist criminal armed gangs did what they could
first, during the War, to attack the British troops in the country when
they were taking an active part in the fight against the Nazis and their
allies. This became worse, from 1945 onwards, when these same criminal
gangs were anxious to drive the indigenous people out of the country.
We have to recognise
that this dates from well before the time when the late unlamented Adolf
Hitler decided that those whom he defined as Jews were the enemy of the
aryan "race" (of whom, incidentally, the most obvious examples are the
rather dark-skinned people of southern India whose Hindu swastika sign he
adopted). I, personally, have never understood this love by the said
Adolf Hitler of such a sign of belonging to a much darker-skinned people.
This strange link
between Nazism and dark-skinned people brings me back to Professor
Shlaim's attempts to separate "good" and "bad" Zionists. The whole
concept of Zionism can only be described as being evil, namely the killing
or expropriation of all the indigenous inhabitants of Palestine, and the
establishment on their ancestral lands of an alien people brought in from
other continents.
I acccordingly call
upon Professor Shlaim to look again at the whole question and to recognise
that the Palestinians are entitled to expect the restitution of their
homes and lands or full compensation for their losses and an absolute
right to return to their land of origin.
*Robert Thompson
is a columnist on Axis of Logic. His writings can be found in "Letters
from France". He is a French citizen, is a retired Avocat (Trial Lawyer)
at the Boulogne-sur-Mer Bar, living with his wife in a small village in
Northern France. He was born at Leek (North Staffordshire, England) in
1931, and, after reading Jurisprudence at Oxford
University,
he became an English Solicitor. He later went to work at the
International Chamber of Commerce in Paris. There he was Director in
charge of the Legal Department and also Secretary General of the Court of
Arbitration, the most important international commercial arbitration
centre on the world. While there, he became the I.C.C. Director in
charge of relations with the Arab states, where he travelled for
professional reasons, and he worked towards legal cooperation with the
countries then within the Comecon.
February 5, 2005
BACK TO TOP ■
COMMENT
© 2004 Bulatlat
■ Alipato Publications Permission is granted to reprint or redistribute this article, provided its author/s and Bulatlat are properly credited and notified. |