By ALDWIN QUITASOL and ARTHUR L. ALLAD-IW
Northern Dispatch
BAGUIO CITY – Residents of this highland city lambasted the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) for issuing a permit to mall giant SM to cut down 182 trees at the Luneta Hill to give way to a pay parking lot.
A clearance signed by Secretary Ramon Paje led to the issuance of permit on October 27 last year for for the cutting, balling, and pruning trees at the Luneta Hill-Governor Pack Road.
More than 2,000 residents had already signed a petition calling for a stop to the cutting and uprooting of trees by SM Baguio.
“DENR shows preferential treatment for business establishments against original inhabitants, locals and residents who have long cared for the environment. Economy at the expense of the environment is greed,” the petition initiated by Michael Bengwayan of the Cordillera Ecological Center.
Residents also questioned the regional DENR office for amending the Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) to SM. Nordis found out that there was no consultation before the permit was issued by Paje and the amended ECC by the DENR-CAR.
The laws on ECC and the local government code mandate for consultation on any projects that would affect or alter the environment before the grant of certifications to any projects.
“There must be consultations with all sectors and stakeholders,” said Faustino Olowan, a former councilor and a practicing lawyer. Olowan also questioned the rights of SM over the land at the Luneta Hill.
Cut corporate greed
Joining the call against cutting of trees are various religious groups.
“As Christians, we are bound to be stalwarts of keepers of the environment and preach about the immorality of greed at the expense of God’s creation and gift to all,” Myke Sotero, a pastor, said.
Benny Dacpano, a leader of taxi drivers association here, said that the Gov. Pack Road can be developed as a first class terminal but not to the extent of sacrificing the fully-grown pine trees.
An official of SM denied the allegations of cutting trees at the Luneta Hill. They will be reballing trees but there would be no cutting, Marc Jansen Pe was quoted in a statement. He admitted though that their new project, the parking area can accommodate 6,000 vehicles.
But the residents claimed they will not take the issue sitting down. “SM is here for business, thinking of profit. It has no concern for the environment. It is us who were born here, who live here,who will protect the environment from its destruction by corporate greed,” a resident said.
In a statement, Anakbayan-Cordillera, College Editors Guild of the Philippines-Baguio-Benguet Chapter, Kabataan Party List-Cordillera and the National Union of Students in the Philippines – Baguio-Benguet Chapter also condemned the plan as it poses danger to the environment.
“With the deteriorating climate condition in Baguio, as further impaired by interrelated events like the growing population, worsening pollution primarily caused by increasing number of vehicles and the congestion of the city, and the garbage crisis; this impending cutting of trees only adds to the problem”, they said.
The youth groups stated they want to save the name of Baguio as being the greenest city.
“Even at the expense of the interests and welfare of the majority, businesses like the SM corporation owned by Henry Sy are unflinching and cannot be deterred in pursuit of greater financial profit”, added the statement.
The youth groups also criticized President Benigno Aquino III for showing no disapproval of the plan.
Residents have called on the public to boycott SM and join street protests and to occupy the area where the cutting and uprooting of trees will be done.
A rally has been set in the afternoon of January 20.
“All at once, this is a fight for saving our environment, a fight against the big businesses’ pursuit of profit at our expense and a call to collectively assert our demands and interests,” the youth groups said. Northern Dispatch
RELATED CONTENTEnvironmentalists hail Baguio City’s ‘ban’ on SM tree-cutting

Filipinos join protests against NATO in Chicago, US (Photo by Brett Jelinek / Bulatlat.com)
Subscribe (RSS or Email) About Us Donate Contact Us Archive Advertise with Bulatlat
January 16th, 2012 at 6:37 pm
Mr. Sy; You could have integrated all the proposed parking into the existing footprint of the mall. Why did you not do this? It would have eliminated the environmental destruction you now propose. Also, why did you not integrate significant numbers of residential condos into the same footprint as the existing mall. This would have eliminated gasoline and parking requirements for thousands of shoppers. Please THINK before you build.
January 17th, 2012 at 5:12 pm
we should prevent global warming…..that’s too much.
January 20th, 2012 at 3:10 pm
[...] however are questioning the DENR’s issuance of permit to the mall giant last Oct. 27 for the cutting, balling and [...]
January 21st, 2012 at 1:13 am
Mas maganda sana kung makakapreserve sia ng mga emerging forests hindi sila pa (SM) ang nagunguna para magka-global warming.
January 31st, 2012 at 7:52 am
[...] City residents decry the lack of public consultations and are questioning the issuance of permit to the mall for the removal of the trees. Student writers hit the [...]
January 31st, 2012 at 12:03 pm
[...] City residents decry the lack of public consultations and are questioning the issuance of permit to the mall for the removal of the trees. Student writers hit the [...]
February 2nd, 2012 at 5:42 am
[...] amin'ny tsy fisian'ny fanontaniana ny heviny ny mponina Baguio ary manontany ny famoahana ny fahazoana alalana azon'ny tranombarotra hanongotra ny hazo. Nandona ny [...]
February 5th, 2012 at 8:21 am
[...] mga tao sa Baguio City nagagalit na hindi sila kinokonsulta at tinatanong nila yun permit ng mall para tanggalin yun mga puno. Mga estudiante-manunulat pinintas yun [...]
February 10th, 2012 at 3:49 pm
found this article, lets us read what SM can say about this issue. http://smsupermalls.com/smsupermalls/smbg/.
upon reading the tree, my concern still remains, its ok to relocate the tree, but will be be healthy for the tree… I wish they would handle it with extreme caution.
February 11th, 2012 at 1:54 pm
Earth balling is harmful to the trees so I hope SM Management really take extra caution when it comes to transferring the trees. I heard SM will hire daw experts sa earth balling eh. And also, sana they fulfill their promise to plant 300 pine tree saplings for every tree transferred.
February 17th, 2012 at 3:35 pm
I beg to disagree with abee,
Earth balling of tree is safe, this method is also being use in other countries, especially the developing countries.
February 22nd, 2012 at 3:53 pm
naisip ko lang, pwede kaya design ng parking is garden. sa top floor since open lahat… and every other floor alternate yung garden area nila.. more tree more plant mas makakalinis ng air..
and after ng building surround nila ng mga trees yung parking area.
April 13th, 2012 at 12:28 pm
[...] Baguio residents protest mall’s plan to cut trees [...]
May 4th, 2012 at 5:38 pm
Talagang hindi tama ang pag putol ng mga puno. Kaya lang ang mga ginagawang actions ng SM ay may patnubay naman ng DENR and pinag aralan ng isang forestry expert na si Fernando Palijon http://www.malaya.com.ph/index.php/business/business-news/2614-forestry-expert-backs-sm-baguio-mall-expansion. Ano ba sa tingin niyo? Mali pa din ba ang ginagawa ng SM kahit na lahat naman ng tamang pamamaraan ginagawa ng SM?